Hafiz Ibn Hajr in his al-Durrar al-Kaminah & Imam al-Dhahabi in his Tarikh mention numerous examples of people who used Hadith in a negative way, mostly for gaining wealth and status and they were not from it's people.
For example They would dictate Hadith for money and didn't know the science but had the chains. Hafiz Ibn al-Jawzi alludes to this in his Talbis Iblis and Sayyid al-Khatir. So, this is the group of people who were known as scholars of Hadith or the people of Hadith who are being Referred to. It was not the Ahl al-Hadith who knew Hadith, their rulings, it's science and how to act upon them.
2. People now rely on these statement of Hafiz Ibn al-Jawzi, and lately his statement on al-Ghazali as his books like Daf Shubhah al-Tashbih and Kitab Akhbar Sifat Hafiz Ibn Rajab quotes Imam Ibn Qudamah (d.620H), who was from Ibn Jawzi (d.597H) era,
"Ibn al-Jawzi was the leading authority of the method of preaching in his era. He also authored excellent works in various sciences, and his efforts were generally accepted. He would teach Fiqh & authored works in this regard, just as he had memorised Hadith & also authored books. However, we are not pleased with his writings & respect to the Sunnah (Aqidah) not his approach (Manhaj)" (Ibn Rajab, al-Dhayl Ala Tabaqat al-Hanabillah 3:446+, Dar al-Uthaymin, 2005)
Al-Ghazali, despite being praised by Ibn al-Jawzi was also heavily reprimanded by him for the latter's lack of skill in Hadith sciences and his usage of weak Hadith.
Al-Ghazali himself alludes to his contemporaries, those from his own school of Ash'arism who refuted him For his lack of skill and weakness in Hadith sciences. This is what led al-Ghazali to revisit Hadith sciences. (Refer to Munqidh Min al-Dalal, where he expressed his spat with his contemporaries)
The point is, to understand differences within a framework which are acceptable And which can be resolved within Ahl al-Sunnah and to make a distinction between the erroneous ways who fall outside of this framework.Statistics: Posted by AbuKhuzaimahAnsari — Mon Jun 22, 2020 1:49 am
]]>